Fiddling with Human Rights Law

December 08, 2008 2:09 PM

Jack Straw has announced that he has plans to "rebalance" the Human Rights Act (HRA). The problem is that this isn't a system that any British politician can balance, adjust or alter at all.


The rights that the HRA enshrines can't be made contingent upon the responsibilities Straw wants to add being met. Equally, he can't do anything about the HRA preventing, for example, radical Islamists being deported.


That isn't how the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), the document that the HRA writes into British law, works. The ECHR doesn't allow for states to balance rights against responsibilities or practical concerns. We can't decide that, for example, in order to ensure a vigorous press we do not want to pass a stringent privacy law. That is not a balance we are free to strike.


Only if we get rid of the ECHR and don't rely on inflexible foreign treaties to defend our liberties will we have the freedom to respond to the concerns Jack Straw seeks to address.

Jack Straw has announced that he has plans to "rebalance" the Human Rights Act (HRA). The problem is that this isn't a system that any British politician can balance, adjust or alter at all.


The rights that the HRA enshrines can't be made contingent upon the responsibilities Straw wants to add being met. Equally, he can't do anything about the HRA preventing, for example, radical Islamists being deported.


That isn't how the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), the document that the HRA writes into British law, works. The ECHR doesn't allow for states to balance rights against responsibilities or practical concerns. We can't decide that, for example, in order to ensure a vigorous press we do not want to pass a stringent privacy law. That is not a balance we are free to strike.


Only if we get rid of the ECHR and don't rely on inflexible foreign treaties to defend our liberties will we have the freedom to respond to the concerns Jack Straw seeks to address.

Latest Blogs:

TaxPayers' Alliance Icon

Who will defend the defenders?

12:03 PM 20, Sep 2017 Duncan Simpson

TaxPayers' Alliance Icon

What’s wrong with the all-ages graduate tax?

6:09 PM 18, Sep 2017 Jan Zeber

TaxPayers' Alliance Icon

Should taxpayers fund Zumba, facials and spas for the NHS?

4:02 PM 18, Sep 2017 Ben Ramanauskas

TaxPayers' Alliance Icon

Charges and fees and more charges and more fees

12:02 AM 06, Sep 2017 Duncan Simpson

TaxPayers' Alliance Icon

Is PFI profit really a waste of taxpayers’ money?

12:05 PM 31, Aug 2017 Jan Zeber