Joined-up hypocrisy on pensions: don't even do as I say

April 22, 2009 7:44 PM

In one of the more mean-minded moves in his Budget, Alistair Darling has decided to claw back tax relief on pension contributions for higher-earners (those with an income over £150,000 pa) from 2011.  But the measure really comes into force from Budget Day, because the Government plans to implement regulations to penalise anyone who, in advance of April 2011, “change their normal ongoing regular pension savings” i.e. saves more into their pension.  If you now decide to save more than £20,000 per year, and you haven’t been doing so already, Alistair will slap an extra tax charge on you.


The logic behind this is pretty obvious.  Darling plans to introduce a new tax band for anyone with an income over £150,000 – originally at 45% from 2011, and now to be at 50% from 2010.  Until now, pension contributions have been eligible for tax relief at the individual’s marginal tax rate – so any one earning more than £150,000 who was worried about the higher rate could simply have paid the surplus income into their pension fund, or agreed to waive that surplus and have their employer pay the amount into the pension instead.  Both of these planning methods will be caught by the transitional tax charge.


In his Budget speech Alistair Darling claimed that “It is difficult to justify how a quarter of all the money the country spends on pensions tax relief goes, as now, to the top 1 ½ per cent of pension savers.”  But that’s what happens when you have a system of tax relief for pension contributions, Alistair: the rich receive more in tax relief because they save more, and they save more because they earn more.  The poor don’t save because they haven’t got any bloody money in the first place.


If salary sacrifice schemes are “unfair” and help only the rich, why does the HM Revenue & Customs website provide detailed advice on how to carry out a salary sacrifice in order to boost your pension contributions?  See here and here.


If Alistair Darling believes people who start to save more are nasty and have to be punished, what does he think of these irresponsible quotes from an evil financier:



“We want to build the savings culture.  That is good for individuals.  It is good for businesses and is therefore good for the country as a whole.  But of course the Government has also to foster the right economic climate to enable businesses and individuals to plan for the long term.” (Alistair Darling, Chief Secretary to the Treasury, 3 December 1997)


“We want to make sure that people on moderate and higher incomes who can save for their retirement, do so….The message that we want to get across to people is that if you can save for your retirement, then you should be saving for your retirement, because it always pays to do so.” (Alistair Darling, Secretary of State for Social Security, 6 April 2001)


“We want to encourage more people to save for their retirement” (Alistair Darling, Secretary of State for Work & Pensions, 30 July 2001)

In one of the more mean-minded moves in his Budget, Alistair Darling has decided to claw back tax relief on pension contributions for higher-earners (those with an income over £150,000 pa) from 2011.  But the measure really comes into force from Budget Day, because the Government plans to implement regulations to penalise anyone who, in advance of April 2011, “change their normal ongoing regular pension savings” i.e. saves more into their pension.  If you now decide to save more than £20,000 per year, and you haven’t been doing so already, Alistair will slap an extra tax charge on you.


The logic behind this is pretty obvious.  Darling plans to introduce a new tax band for anyone with an income over £150,000 – originally at 45% from 2011, and now to be at 50% from 2010.  Until now, pension contributions have been eligible for tax relief at the individual’s marginal tax rate – so any one earning more than £150,000 who was worried about the higher rate could simply have paid the surplus income into their pension fund, or agreed to waive that surplus and have their employer pay the amount into the pension instead.  Both of these planning methods will be caught by the transitional tax charge.


In his Budget speech Alistair Darling claimed that “It is difficult to justify how a quarter of all the money the country spends on pensions tax relief goes, as now, to the top 1 ½ per cent of pension savers.”  But that’s what happens when you have a system of tax relief for pension contributions, Alistair: the rich receive more in tax relief because they save more, and they save more because they earn more.  The poor don’t save because they haven’t got any bloody money in the first place.


If salary sacrifice schemes are “unfair” and help only the rich, why does the HM Revenue & Customs website provide detailed advice on how to carry out a salary sacrifice in order to boost your pension contributions?  See here and here.


If Alistair Darling believes people who start to save more are nasty and have to be punished, what does he think of these irresponsible quotes from an evil financier:



“We want to build the savings culture.  That is good for individuals.  It is good for businesses and is therefore good for the country as a whole.  But of course the Government has also to foster the right economic climate to enable businesses and individuals to plan for the long term.” (Alistair Darling, Chief Secretary to the Treasury, 3 December 1997)


“We want to make sure that people on moderate and higher incomes who can save for their retirement, do so….The message that we want to get across to people is that if you can save for your retirement, then you should be saving for your retirement, because it always pays to do so.” (Alistair Darling, Secretary of State for Social Security, 6 April 2001)


“We want to encourage more people to save for their retirement” (Alistair Darling, Secretary of State for Work & Pensions, 30 July 2001)

Latest Blogs:

TaxPayers' Alliance Icon

Working for the taxman

6:00 AM 26, Nov 2016 Harry Fairhead

TaxPayers' Alliance Icon

Further thoughts on the Autumn Statement

4:56 PM 24, Nov 2016 James Price

TaxPayers' Alliance Icon

Have we had too much austerity?

10:57 AM 23, Nov 2016 Alex Wild

TaxPayers' Alliance Icon

Launch a War on Waste and simplify taxes

9:45 AM 23, Nov 2016 The TaxPayers' Alliance

TaxPayers' Alliance Icon

Reforming capital taxes

6:00 AM 19, Nov 2016 Harry Fairhead