A gimmick or real local democracy?

July 05, 2007 5:49 PM

We can be forgiven for being a bit sceptical about Gordon Brown’s initiative to make local spending subject to local ballots.


The idea is welcome and it’s high time the people had a say over where their council tax is spent.  Given the record of this government, however, we’re minded to think this will be a gimmick and little more.


At present 80% of local government revenue is provided by Whitehall.  We have one of the most centralised systems of local government in the world – why else is there such a poor turnout in local elections? 


For this to become a real change that can benefit taxpayers and give residents a greater say, these moves need to extend beyond small spending commitments on parks or local statues.  We need councils to put their spending plans to the people, initiating a thorough debate on where taxpayers’ money should be spent.  This, as well as fundamental reform of local government finance, will go a great way to restoring some trust in government.  Without these necessary reforms the British people will stay away from the polls as local democracy continues to languish as a political myth.

We can be forgiven for being a bit sceptical about Gordon Brown’s initiative to make local spending subject to local ballots.


The idea is welcome and it’s high time the people had a say over where their council tax is spent.  Given the record of this government, however, we’re minded to think this will be a gimmick and little more.


At present 80% of local government revenue is provided by Whitehall.  We have one of the most centralised systems of local government in the world – why else is there such a poor turnout in local elections? 


For this to become a real change that can benefit taxpayers and give residents a greater say, these moves need to extend beyond small spending commitments on parks or local statues.  We need councils to put their spending plans to the people, initiating a thorough debate on where taxpayers’ money should be spent.  This, as well as fundamental reform of local government finance, will go a great way to restoring some trust in government.  Without these necessary reforms the British people will stay away from the polls as local democracy continues to languish as a political myth.

Latest Blogs:

A joint letter to the Telegraph - cutting fuel bills

10:59 AM 29, Apr 2017 John O'Connell

TaxPayers' Alliance Icon

Sadiq Khan right to take taxpayers off hook for Garden Bridge

11:29 AM 28, Apr 2017 The TaxPayers' Alliance

TaxPayers' Alliance Icon

TPA’s proposals adopted by Select Committee

4:34 PM 27, Apr 2017 Jan Zeber

TaxPayers' Alliance Icon

Inquiry into government accounts - Written evidence

10:00 AM 27, Apr 2017 The TaxPayers' Alliance

TaxPayers' Alliance Icon

The Conservative Manifesto: Joint note by the TPA and IEA

10:48 AM 26, Apr 2017 The TaxPayers' Alliance