How to 'free the NHS from government interference

February 21, 2008 12:37 PM

The Telegraph reports a call by the British Medical Association for NHS independence:

"An NHS constitution should be used to free the health service from the day-to-day interference of Government ministers, doctors' representatives have claimed."

We absolutely agree.  However, if you're going to make the NHS independent there are two things that you need to do at the same time:


  1. Decentralise.  While a NHS board might have more healthcare experience it would operate from the centre, probably from Whitehall, so could quickly become out of touch with the priorities of local healthcare organisations.  We should give real freedom to local organisations that can respond to the needs and circumstances of their area.

  2. Allow competition.  An independent NHS can't mean that producers are left to spend billions of pounds without proper accountability to the public who use and fund the service.  Ordinary people should be able to, through the threat of taking their business elsewhere, hold providers to account themselves.  Healthcare systems in continental European countries reap the benefits of competition, particularly in the Netherlands, without compromising universal service.

If the BMA will sign up to those principles we'll support their call for NHS independence wholeheartedly.

The Telegraph reports a call by the British Medical Association for NHS independence:

"An NHS constitution should be used to free the health service from the day-to-day interference of Government ministers, doctors' representatives have claimed."

We absolutely agree.  However, if you're going to make the NHS independent there are two things that you need to do at the same time:


  1. Decentralise.  While a NHS board might have more healthcare experience it would operate from the centre, probably from Whitehall, so could quickly become out of touch with the priorities of local healthcare organisations.  We should give real freedom to local organisations that can respond to the needs and circumstances of their area.

  2. Allow competition.  An independent NHS can't mean that producers are left to spend billions of pounds without proper accountability to the public who use and fund the service.  Ordinary people should be able to, through the threat of taking their business elsewhere, hold providers to account themselves.  Healthcare systems in continental European countries reap the benefits of competition, particularly in the Netherlands, without compromising universal service.

If the BMA will sign up to those principles we'll support their call for NHS independence wholeheartedly.

Latest Blogs:

TaxPayers' Alliance Icon

How should we fund social care?

10:43 AM 20, Jan 2017 Alex Wild

TaxPayers' Alliance Icon

We're hiring a Campaign Manager - Digital

11:37 AM 16, Jan 2017 The TaxPayers' Alliance

TaxPayers' Alliance Icon

Increases in precepts are not the answer

3:30 PM 13, Jan 2017 James Price

TaxPayers' Alliance Icon

We must all stand up for a free press

10:39 AM 06, Jan 2017 Dia Chakravarty

TaxPayers' Alliance Icon

Want to be our new Policy Analyst?

12:52 PM 05, Jan 2017 The TaxPayers' Alliance